What Happens When Cities Go Bankrupt???

What a great question posed in this recent article by the Third Branch News!  I read an article this morning: http://news.uscourts.gov/when-cities-go-bankrupt and thought it gave GREAT insight as to where we as a country are headed. 

The City of Detroit filed for relief under Chapter 9 of the United States Bankruptcy Code on July 1, 2013, recording the largest, most significant municipal bankruptcy filing in history.  The statistic in the above referenced article that most astonished me was, “Chapter 9 filings are not common. From 1991-2012 there were 217 Chapter 9 bankruptcies filed nationwide, with 20 filed in [Fiscal Year] 2012.”  The 2012 filings were twice the number of filings under Chapter 9 than the average in the past 20 years and more than 3 times the average since Congress enacted the law in 1934 allowing municipalities to file for bankruptcy relief.  Our cities are increasingly becoming more and more poor as time goes on.

The Washington Post says that Detroit lost over a million residents over the past 60 years, one-quarter of which left from 2000 to 2012, and with them went their tax dollars.  Loss of tax revenue coupled with decreased state aid and a huge economic hit to the auto industry – the city’s major export, have left the city’s finances crippled. 

So what happens with a city files bankruptcy?  It can use its property to raise revenue, raise taxes, and “adjust” debt (i.e. not pay).  They can even reject retiree benefit plans – cut the pensions and retirement benefits for our senior citizens!

As I research the issues surrounding Chapter 9 filings, I’ve found that a municipality seeking relief under Chapter 9 is allowed more freedom to operate its “business” without court imposed restrictions and does not have to seek court approval for many acts as a Chapter 11 debtor normally would.  The municipality still has to file a feasible plan for reorganization.  Here is where we assess the “best interests of the creditor test,” but it’s held to a different standard under a Chapter 9 filing than it ever would in a Chapter 11 filing.  That’s because the best interest of the creditors is far different when you evaluate creditor options collecting against a normal entity vs. a municipality.

If a normal business filed Chapter 11, proposed reorganization and then either (1) didn’t get the plan confirmed or (2) defaulted on the confirmed plan, a creditor could attempt to collect its debt through normal state court actions.  Creditor gets a Judgment and then executes on said Judgment, typically either by garnishment, lien or levy.  A Chapter 9 case is different … because – how do you collect from a municipality?  Can you imagine the pandemonium if Judgment creditors started going down to City Hall with the Sherriff and asking the City Clerk to empty out the cash drawer?????

The practical application of this Chapter basically tells general creditors that they can either agree to whatever ludicrous plan the municipality proposes or the municipality can simply put its feet on its desk and say, “Come get me – go ahead, try to collect.”  Then creditors can start suing municipalities one by one, getting Judgments that aren’t even worth the piece of paper they’re printed on.

For more information on bankruptcy, please visit www.abankruptcyfirm.com/ or contact your local Kansas City Bankruptcy Lawyer, Betsy Lynch, at 816.434.6616.

9 Comments

    July 25, 2013 REPLY

    I have had some problems with bankruptcy in London Ontario. Who could I contact to get some help.

    August 2, 2013 REPLY

    Thanks for the post. I recently had a chat with my husband about filing for bankruptcy in Canada. I am so worried about what is going to happen and think I need a lawyer. Do you have any suggestions for me?

    August 13, 2013 REPLY

    The statement "Our cities are increasingly becoming more and more poor as time goes on." is upsetting. But as technology and industries shift, it is to be expected. Luckily, bankruptcy in Indianapolis isn't an issue as of yet. We are a city that continues to see growth.

    September 18, 2013 REPLY

    Good question. It's hard when an individual goes through it. I have a friend that is looking into bankruptcy in Ontario. I can't imagine a city going through bankruptcy.

    September 23, 2013 REPLY

    One of the main benifit of Payday Loansis that it is very easy to obtain one quickly.

    Fast Cash Loans

    November 12, 2013 REPLY

    Thank you for the post! I love reading your blog. It is very informative. I came across it trying to research bankruptcy in Toronto. I have learned a lot from your posts! Thanks again.

    November 22, 2013 REPLY

    Very Nice post, very beautyfully described the effect of bankruptcy on cities, When bankruptcy occurs the economic rate of city decreases and bad effect puts on image of municipality California Abogados De Bancarrota

    December 3, 2013 REPLY

    Hi there! this is such an informative post. Thank you for sharing. Cheers!

    – The malden ma bankruptcy

    February 18, 2014 REPLY

    I am a law student and read the information shared above and liked it. It is really nice and informative. Thanks for sharing such a great content.

leave a comment